[G52] Are non-migrating family members exempt from health checks, and do all skilled migration visas have a health waiver?
Health (PIC), PIC 4020 & Character (Form 1563) · Fact-Checked 2026-11-12 · Sources: F-REG-V2: 189.225, 189.314(6)(b), 190.216, 491.211, 191.211; F-REG-V3: PIC4005; PIC4007(2); F-P-200941: §§6.11.1–6.11.3
- If we list our child with a developmental condition as non-migrating on our 190 application, does that avoid the health requirement?
- Can we apply for a health cost waiver under PIC 4005 if our Subclass 491 application is refused on medical grounds?
No on both counts. Standard Subclass 189 (Points-tested), Subclass 190, and Subclass 491 visas apply Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4005, whereas Subclass 191 applies PIC 4007. PIC 4005 has no discretionary health cost waiver equivalent to PIC 4007(2). In addition, clauses 189.225, 190.216, 491.211, and 191.211 extend statutory health criteria to non-migrating members of the family unit (unless a specific 'unreasonable to require assessment' policy setting applies). Removing a child or partner from the migrating application does not make a health issue disappear, and the narrow reference to PIC 4007 in cl 189.314(6)(b) for certain family-violence secondary cases does not create a general health waiver across Subclass 189.
- Core Legal Rule: No on both counts. Standard Subclass 189 (Points-tested), Subclass 190, and Subclass 491 visas apply Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4005, whereas Subclass 191 applies PIC 4007. PIC 4005 has no discretionary health cost waiver equivalent to PIC 4007(2). In addition, clauses 189.225, 190.216, 491.211, and 191.211 extend statutory health criteria to non-migrating members of the family unit (unless a specific 'unreasonable to require assessment' policy setting applies). Removing a child or partner from the migrating application does not make a health issue disappear, and the narrow reference to PIC 4007 in cl 189.314(6)(b) for certain family-violence secondary cases does not create a general health waiver across Subclass 189.
- When Individual Legal Review Is Needed: Where any migrating or non-migrating family member has a significant medical condition or disability, identify whether the subclass applies PIC 4005 (no cost waiver, though updated MOC opinions may be sought on review as in Ali [2025] ARTA 3034) or PIC 4007 (waiver available for Subclass 191), and assess whether a non-migrating examination is required.
- Applicable Scope & Subclasses: Health (PIC), PIC 4020 & Character (Form 1563) (Subclass 189 · 190 · 491 · 191)
Park & Co Lawyers · Legal Consultation Guide Consultation Guide
1. Primary statutory, instrument and case law framework (G52)
Schedule 2 clauses 189.225, 190.216, and 491.211 impose Schedule 4 PIC 4005 across primary applicants and both migrating and non-migrating MoFUs, while cl 191.211 applies PIC 4007 (which includes the PIC 4007(2) waiver power; note also the specific reference to PIC 4007 in cl 189.314(6)(b) for certain family-violence secondary cases). Departmental policy on when it is 'unreasonable' to require a non-migrating family member to undergo a medical examination (PAM3 Health §§6.11.1–6.11.3) is distinct from a statutory health waiver.
2. Common misconceptions and practical traps
Two widespread myths cause devastating refusals: first, that switching a child with a medical condition to 'non-migrating' (or omitting them) avoids the health test; second, that Subclass 491 has a health waiver because it is a provisional visa. Under the 'one fails, all fail' framework in clauses 189.225, 190.216, and 491.211, non-migrating family unit members remain subject to the health criteria, and policy settings that sometimes dispense with routine medical exams do not equate to a legal waiver if a health threshold is failed. Likewise, Ali (Migration) [2025] ARTA 3034 succeeded on Subclass 491 review only because an updated Medical Officer of the Commonwealth (MOC) opinion found PIC 4005(1)(c) met - not because PIC 4005 contains a waiver.
3. When individual legal assessment is required
- Key review point: Where any migrating or non-migrating family member has a significant medical condition or disability. Identify whether the subclass applies PIC 4005 (no cost waiver, though updated MOC opinions may be sought on review as in Ali [2025] ARTA 3034) or PIC 4007 (waiver available for Subclass 191), and assess whether a non-migrating examination is required.
4. Interactive points and state nomination check
- Check your Schedule 6D points, partner points, and 8-state nomination rules in our interactive tool: Open GSM & State Nomination Navigator
5. Primary authorities and verification scope (checked 12 November 2026)
- Primary authorities: F-REG-V2: 189.225, 189.314(6)(b), 190.216, 491.211, 191.211; F-REG-V3: PIC4005; PIC4007(2); F-P-200941: §§6.11.1–6.11.3
- Scope note: This guide explains the statutory framework and corrects common misconceptions as general legal information. It does not assess individual prospects of success or replace tailored legal advice.
Pre-Consultation & Pre-Lodgement Checklist Checklist
- Confirm every point claimed in your SkillSelect EOI and state ROI is backed by primary evidence as at the invitation date
- Key threshold to verify: Where any migrating or non-migrating family member has a significant medical condition or disability. Identify whether the subclass applies PIC 4005 (no cost waiver, though updated MOC opinions may be sought on review as in Ali [2025] ARTA 3034) or PIC 4007 (waiver available for Subclass 191), and assess whether a non-migrating examination is required.
- Cross-check skills assessment validity, English test dates (LIN 25/016 and regs 1.15C–1.15EA), and partner status (Grewal)
- For Subclass 491 holders, maintain regional compliance (Conditions 8578–8581) and retain 3 ATO Notices of Assessment for Subclass 191 (cl 191.224)
- Run the Park & Co GSM & State Nomination Navigator to review linked statutory thresholds and the 8-State Matrix
General Skilled Migration (189 · 190 · 491) & State Navigator
Simulate Schedule 6D points and compare state nomination residence and occupation rules.