Strict 21-Day Limit Strict 21-day filing limit · extension possible only in exceptional circumstances under s 394(3) / s 366(2) (next business day if Day 21 is a weekend/public holiday) · Employer F3 response: 7 days after receiving copy from FWC / F8A: 7 days after FWC request · Sponsored 482/494 cessation: 180 days

Pre-Dismissal HR & Procedural Fairness Checklist for Australian Employers: PIPs, Show Cause & Redundancy

Complying with Fair Work Act ss 117, 387, 388 & 389 across poor performance PIPs, serious misconduct Show Cause letters, <15 small business checklists, and genuine redundancy consultations

Law Verified: 2026-11-07 · Reviewed by: Chang Min Park (Legal Practitioner Director / Accredited Specialist in Immigration Law) · Kevin Park, Associate (Employment Law) · General Legal Information
Representative Client Questions
  • We paid full notice in lieu when letting go of an underperforming worker - why can they still bring an FWC Unfair Dismissal claim?
  • Even when serious misconduct appears clear on CCTV, why must HR suspend on pay and issue a written Show Cause letter before summary dismissal?
  • What procedural traps invalidate a genuine redundancy defence or a Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (<15 staff) defence?
Key Answer Summary (TL;DR)

For an Australian employer to dismiss an employee lawfully and defend an unfair dismissal claim, the process must match the specific ground of termination - capacity/performance, misconduct, or genuine redundancy - under sections 117 and 387 to 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and any applicable Modern Award, Enterprise Agreement, or workplace policy. While written warnings and a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) are best-practice tools for unsatisfactory performance, the Act does not prescribe a mandatory one-size-fits-all PIP duration for every dismissal. Instead, the FWC weighs the section 387 fairness factors on the facts of each case and, for redundancies, tests section 389 consultation and reasonable redeployment (including contractor replacement feasibility under Helensburgh Coal [2025] HCA 29).

  • Poor Performance Requires Warnings & PIP: For an Australian employer to dismiss an employee lawfully and defend an unfair dismissal claim, the process must match the specific ground of termination - capacity/performance, misconduct, or genuine redundancy - under sections 117 and 387 to 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and any applicable Modern Award, Enterprise Agreement, or workplace policy. While written warnings and a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) are best-practice tools for unsatisfactory performance, the Act does not prescribe a mandatory one-size-fits-all PIP duration for every dismissal. Instead, the FWC weighs the section 387 fairness factors on the facts of each case and, for redundancies, tests section 389 consultation and reasonable redeployment (including contractor replacement feasibility under Helensburgh Coal [2025] HCA 29).
  • Serious Misconduct Still Needs Show Cause: Even for reg 1.07 theft, fraud, or WHS breaches, employers should suspend on full pay, issue written Show Cause allegations, offer a support person, and genuinely weigh responses before summary dismissal.
  • <15 Small Business Headcount & Code Rules: Small business (<15) headcount includes regular casuals and all Corporations Act s 50AAA associated entity staff; employers should complete and retain the FWC Small Business Fair Dismissal Code checklist.
Recommended Next Step: Park & Co Lawyers · Employment Law Practice Australian Employment Law Consultation & Scope ↗

Park & Co Lawyers · Legal Consultation Guide Consultation Guide

1. Managing poor performance (s 387(e)): Formal warnings and structured PIPs

When dismissal relates to unsatisfactory work performance or skill deficits, the Fair Work Commission (FWC) must consider under s 387(e) whether the employee was formally warned about that unsatisfactory performance prior to dismissal and given a genuine opportunity to improve. Casual verbal reminders during corridor chats rarely satisfy the statutory standard.

Best-practice performance management follows three documented stages: (1) issue a Formal Written Warning identifying specific KPI or quality shortfalls and expressly stating that continued underperformance may result in termination of employment. (2) implement a structured Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) over a reasonable review window (typically 4 to 8 weeks) with clear benchmarks, training/coaching support, and documented check-ins. And (3) if targets remain unmet, issue a final meeting invitation offering a support person (s 387(d)) to hear any mitigating explanation before deciding termination.

Dismissal PathwayStatutory AnchorMandatory Pre-Termination StepsNotice (s 117) & Final Payout
Poor PerformanceFWA s 387(a)-(e)Written warning stating dismissal risk · structured PIP & coaching · final response meetingWritten s 117 notice (1-5 wks) or payment in lieu
Serious MisconductFair Work Regs reg 1.07 · s 387Suspension on full pay · impartial inquiry · written Show Cause & support person · consider replySummary dismissal without notice if proved (annual leave still paid)
Small Business (<15 Staff)FWA ss 23, 388Verify <15 headcount incl. s 50AAA group · comply with Small Business Fair Dismissal CodeWritten s 117 notice (unless valid summary dismissal) + retain Code checklist
Genuine RedundancyFWA ss 119, 389Operational job abolition · Modern Award consultation · s 50AAA redeployment checkWritten notice + s 119 redundancy pay (>=15 staff)
Practical Caution: Walking into a disciplinary meeting with a pre-signed termination letter already printed in your folder is treated by the FWC as a fatal fait accompli breach of s 387(b)-(c). Always adjourn after hearing the employee's response to consider their explanation genuinely before making a decision.

2. Serious misconduct (reg 1.07): Paid suspension and show cause natural justice

Under Fair Work Regulations 2009 reg 1.07, serious misconduct encompasses wilful or deliberate behaviour inconsistent with continuing the employment contract - including theft, fraud, assault, workplace sexual harassment, intoxication at work, serious WHS breaches, or refusal to obey a lawful and reasonable instruction. Yet firing an employee on the spot by text message or heated verbal confrontation routinely turns a winning misconduct defence into a losing procedural-unfairness ruling.

Follow four disciplined steps instead: Step 1: Place the worker on immediate suspension on full pay while confirming no disciplinary outcome has been pre-judged. Step 2: Gather CCTV, digital logs, and witness statements impartially, then issue a written Allegations & Show Cause Letter particularising dates, conduct, and potential dismissal consequences. Step 3: Offer a support person and allow at least 24 to 48+ hours for a written and/or in-person response. Step 4: Weigh the worker's response and service record objectively to the requisite evidentiary standard before issuing any written summary dismissal notice.

3. Small business (<15 headcount) fair dismissal code (s 388) and group counting traps

Employers with fewer than 15 employees at the time of dismissal benefit from a 12-month minimum employment period (s 383) and the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (s 388). Strict compliance with the Code acts as a complete jurisdictional shield against Unfair Dismissal.

Two recurring traps catch Korean-Australian business owners off guard. First, s 23 counts headcount (not full-time equivalents), sweeping in full-time, part-time, regular/systematic casuals, the dismissed worker, and every employee of Corporations Act s 50AAA associated entities (such as sister restaurants, franchises, or sibling trusts controlled by common directors or shareholders). Second, for non-summary dismissals, the Code still requires a valid reason, prior warning that the employee risks dismissal, and a reasonable chance to rectify, documented contemporaneously on the official FWC Code Checklist.

4. Genuine redundancy (s 389), written s 117 notice and 7-day payday super

Downsizing due to slower revenue qualifies as a Genuine Redundancy (s 389) only if all three statutory limbs are proved: (1) nobody is required to perform the employee's job due to operational changes (s 389(1)(a)). (2) the employer strictly performed every written consultation step in any applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement before locking in the termination (s 389(1)(b)), and (3) reasonable redeployment across the employer and all s 50AAA associated entities was genuinely explored and unavailable (s 389(2)).

Finally, under section 117, termination (other than proved serious misconduct) must be given in writing specifying the termination date. Providing statutory notice (1 to 4 weeks by tenure, plus 1 extra week if the employee is over 45 years old with at least 2 years' continuous service) or payment in lieu at the full rate of pay, alongside s 119 redundancy pay (4-16 weeks for >=15 headcount employers). Accrued unused annual leave must be paid out promptly, and under Payday Super (1 July 2026), 12% superannuation on final Qualifying Earnings must clear into the employee's super fund within 7 business days.

Practical Caution: Screen for General Protections (Part 3-1) exposure before every termination: if the worker recently queried wages/super, took sick leave (s 352), lodged WorkCover, or exercised the Right to Disconnect (s 333M), Form F8 applies from Day 1 of employment with uncapped damages and a s 361 reverse onus.

5. Final pre-dismissal HR verification checklist

  • Signed employment contract, position description, Modern Award classification check, and guaranteed earnings review ($190,100 HIT check)
  • Exact headcount schedule at termination date aggregating regular casuals and all s 50AAA associated entity staff (<15 vs >=15)
  • For poor performance: signed written warning(s) stating dismissal risk, structured PIP schedule, coaching logs, and review notes
  • For serious misconduct: paid suspension notice, particularised written Show Cause letter, support-person offer, and response evaluation memo
  • For redundancy: operational restructure paper trail, written Modern Award consultation letters/minutes, and group-wide redeployment audit
  • General Protections risk check confirming zero link to workplace complaints, sick leave, parental leave, or Right to Disconnect
  • Formal written s 117 termination letter incorporating exact tenure notice (including over-45 bonus week) or payment-in-lieu calculation
  • Final pay breakdown (unused annual leave, LSL, s 119 redundancy pay) and 7-business-day 12% Payday Super payment scheduling

12 November 2026 statutory audit update and employee/employer dual-perspective guide

1. Statutory audit verification (Fair Work Act 2009 (cth) ss 117, 387–389; helensburgh coal pty ltd v bartley [2025] HCA 29)

While written warnings and a structured PIP are strong practical evidence under section 387(e), the Fair Work Act does not impose a rigid statutory PIP template on every dismissal; the FWC assesses procedural and substantive fairness across all section 387 factors alongside applicable award or contract rules. For redundancies under section 389(2), the High Court confirmed in Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29 ([36]–[41]) that reasonable redeployment is not restricted to checking pre-existing vacant roles and can include assessing whether contractor work within the enterprise could reasonably be reallocated to displaced employees.

2. Redeployment audits, serious misconduct and decision-maker records (expansions: Employer-05, employer-06, employer-20)

  • What Employers Must Check: Document clear performance standards and support for performance management. Provide written particulars, a genuine response opportunity, and any requested support person before deciding on alleged serious misconduct. And for redundancies, record award consultation and broad redeployment checks (including contractor roles per Helensburgh Coal) before issuing written notice under section 117.
  • What Employees Should Do: Keep copies of all PIP documents, restructuring notices, and job advertisements or contractor engagements replacing your duties, and note the 21-day FWC deadline from dismissal taking effect.
  • Exceptions & Deadlines: Written termination notice must be given under section 117, and FWC dismissal claims close 21 calendar days after dismissal takes effect.

Pre-Consultation & Pre-Lodgement Checklist Checklist

  • Employment contract, position description, Modern Award coverage check, and guaranteed earnings review against the $190,100 HIT
  • Headcount audit on termination date aggregating regular casuals and all Corporations Act s 50AAA associated entity staff
  • For poor performance: signed written warning(s) stating dismissal risk, structured PIP benchmarks, and coaching records
  • For serious misconduct: paid suspension letter, particularised written Show Cause notice, support-person offer, and decision memo
  • For genuine redundancy: operational restructure rationale, written Modern Award consultation records, and group redeployment check
  • General Protections screening confirming zero connection to wage inquiries, sick leave, WorkCover, or Right to Disconnect
  • Written section 117 termination notice incorporating exact tenure weeks (plus 1 week if over 45 with >=2 years' service) or pay in lieu
  • Final pay calculation (accrued annual leave, LSL, s 119 redundancy pay) and 7-business-day 12% Payday Super remittance schedule
In-Depth Column · Read Practical Background & Case Flow

"An employee kept making costly mistakes and arriving late, so we told them Friday would be their last day and paid out their full notice. Why did we still get hit with an FWC Unfair Dismissal claim?"

Few moments frustrate Australian business owners more than paying full notice entitlements to a genuinely underperforming worker, only to receive a Fair Work Commission (FWC) application demanding compensation. The explanation lies at the heart of Fair Work Act s 387: Australian workplace law weighs how you dismiss (procedural fairness) just as heavily as why you dismiss (valid reason). Skipping formal warnings, Show Cause meetings, or Award consultation routinely turns a justified termination into a costly Unfair Dismissal payout (capped at $95,050 in FY 2026-27). ## Poor Performance (PIPs) vs Serious Misconduct (Show Cause)

Ending employment over poor performance requires a documented paper trail long before the final meeting. Informal verbal reminders rarely count. Under s 387(e), employers need a Formal Written Warning spelling out concrete KPI shortfalls and explicitly warning that employment is at risk, followed by a structured Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) providing coaching and a fair review window. What about Serious Misconduct (reg 1.07) such as theft, fraud, violence, or severe safety breaches? Even when wrongdoing is caught on camera, firing someone on the spot by text or heated confrontation frequently backfires under s 387(b)-(c). Instead, place the worker on suspension on full pay, issue a written Show Cause letter detailing the allegations, offer a support person, and genuinely consider their explanation before deciding summary dismissal. | Scenario | Mandatory Pre-Termination Process | Classic Employer Pitfall |

:---:---:---
Poor PerformanceWritten dismissal-risk warning + structured PIP reviewRelying on casual verbal chats before sudden dismissal
Serious MisconductPaid suspension + written Show Cause + support personInstant verbal or text dismissal without hearing a reply
Small Business (<15 Staff)Count s 50AAA group headcount + retain Code ChecklistIgnoring sister-company or regular casual headcount
Genuine RedundancyModern Award written consultation + redeployment checkAnnouncing redundancy as a done deal without consultation

Small Business Headcount Traps. Redundancy Consultation & Final Payday Super

Before relying on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (s 388), verify your true headcount (s 23). You must count regular casuals plus every employee working across s 50AAA associated entities under shared directorial or shareholding control. Similarly, a Genuine Redundancy (s 389) collapses if HR forgets to run written Modern Award consultation before making the final decision or fails to check redeployment across related entities. Finally, lock down the exit mechanics: issue a written termination notice (s 117) reflecting tenure and the extra week for staff aged over 45 with 2+ years' service, pay out accrued unused annual leave, and remit 12% Payday Super so it clears into the worker's super fund within 7 business days of final pay. A single pre-termination legal check prevents months of tribunal stress - run your scenario through the Park & Co Employment Law Navigator or contact our team via the Park & Co Consultation Hub or enquiry@parkcolawyers.com. This article provides general Australian employment and workplace law information current as at 7 November 2026 and does not constitute legal advice for individual matters. Assessments may vary depending on applicable Modern Awards, contract terms, and specific factual circumstances.

Tailored Self-Assessment Tool

Park & Co Australian Employment Law Navigator (Strict 21-Day Limit & Triage)

Strict 21-day filing limit — extension possible only in exceptional circumstances under s 394(3) (next business day if Day 21 is a weekend/public holiday); compare Form F2 vs Form F8, check ABN sham contracting, and review Condition 8607 180-day visa protections.

Launch Employment Navigator ↗
[Park & Co Engagement Scope] Park & Co Lawyers advises Australian employers on pre-dismissal strategy, Show Cause processes, PIP documentation, and redundancy compliance, excluding clerical payslip or final-pay arithmetic calculations.
02 Related Questions

Related Representative Questions

More in This Category
04 Park & Co Legal Services & Direct Assistance

Park & Co Lawyers · Employment Law Diagnostic Tools & Representation

Check your 21-day FWC filing limit and Modern Award rates for free first, or engage our Employment Law team for FWC advocacy, Deed of Release negotiations, and employer defence.

Open Official Inquiry Hub ↗

Solicitor Representation & HR Advisory

Employment Practice
FWC Unfair Dismissal (Form F2) & General Protections (Form F8) Representation

Drafting Form F2/F8 applications or employer Form F3/F8A response...

Employer HR Compliance, Employment Contracts & Show Cause Advisory

Modern Award classification audits, procedurally fair disciplinar...

Transparent Cost-Benefit & Engagement Scope Policy

Because Fair Work matters operate in a strict no-costs jurisdiction (s 570), Park & Co Lawyers guides small wage-arrears claims to free self-calculation tools rather than charging hourly calculation fees, focusing legal representation on high-stakes dismissal, general protections, visa-linked workplace disputes, and employer compliance.