Strict 21-Day Limit Strict 21-day filing limit · extension possible only in exceptional circumstances under s 394(3) / s 366(2) (next business day if Day 21 is a weekend/public holiday) · Employer F3 response: 7 days after receiving copy from FWC / F8A: 7 days after FWC request · Sponsored 482/494 cessation: 180 days

Genuine Redundancy (s 389) Three Mandatory Limbs and NES Statutory Redundancy Pay (s 119) in Australia

Fair Work Act s 389 operational change, mandatory Modern Award consultation, and s 50AAA redeployment rules, plus s 117 notice and the s 119 4-to-16-week severance pay table

Law Verified: 2026-11-07 · Reviewed by: Chang Min Park (Legal Practitioner Director / Accredited Specialist in Immigration Law) · Kevin Park, Associate (Employment Law) · General Legal Information
Representative Client Questions
  • My employer made my role redundant citing downturn, yet advertised a cheaper junior role doing the exact same job days later. Can I lodge a Form F2 unfair dismissal claim?
  • Does failing to follow Modern Award consultation clauses destroy a genuine redundancy defence even in a small business?
  • How are NES statutory notice (s 117) and redundancy pay (s 119, 4 to 16 weeks) calculated, and why does severance drop from 16 weeks to 12 weeks at 10 years' service?
Key Answer Summary (TL;DR)

Under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a genuine redundancy requires that the job is no longer required to be performed by anyone, applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement consultation obligations are met, and redeployment within the employer or associated entities was not reasonable in all the circumstances (s 389(2)). Under High Court authority in Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29 ([7], [34]–[41]), the section 389(2) redeployment inquiry is not confined solely to existing advertised vacancies and may consider whether contractor work or workforce arrangements could reasonably be reorganised. Though it does not impose an automatic rule requiring employers to terminate contractors or create new roles. NES redundancy pay (s 119) scales up to 16 weeks at 9–10 years and 12 weeks at 10+ years.

  • 3 Mandatory Limbs of s 389 Redundancy: Under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a genuine redundancy requires that the job is no longer required to be performed by anyone, applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement consultation obligations are met, and redeployment within the employer or associated entities was not reasonable in all the circumstances (s 389(2)). Under High Court authority in Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29 ([7], [34]–[41]), the section 389(2) redeployment inquiry is not confined solely to existing advertised vacancies and may consider whether contractor work or workforce arrangements could reasonably be reorganised. Though it does not impose an automatic rule requiring employers to terminate contractors or create new roles. NES redundancy pay (s 119) scales up to 16 weeks at 9–10 years and 12 weeks at 10+ years.
  • Award Consultation Failure = Unfair Dismissal: Presenting redundancy as a locked-in fait accompli without two-way Award consultation destroys s 389 immunity (even for <15 small businesses), opening Form F2 within 21 calendar days.
  • NES Severance Scale: 4 to 16 Weeks (s 119): Permanent staff with 1+ year service at 15+ employers receive 4 to 16 weeks' base pay; at 10+ years, severance drops from 16 weeks to 12 weeks to offset statutory Long Service Leave accrual.
Recommended Next Step: Park & Co Lawyers · Employment Law Practice Australian Employment Law Consultation & Scope ↗

Park & Co Lawyers · Legal Consultation Guide Consultation Guide

1. The three mandatory limbs of genuine redundancy (FWA s 389)

In an unfair dismissal proceeding (s 385(d)), genuine redundancy is a jurisdictional defence where the evidentiary burden rests on the employer across every limb:

Statutory LimbLegal Requirement (FWA s 389)Classic Failure / Sham Redundancy Scenario
Limb 1: Job No Longer Required (s 389(1)(a))Operational changes mean the employee's job (collection of functions, duties, and responsibilities) no longer needs to be performed by anyoneRedistributing residual tasks among existing staff is lawful. But advertising a slightly renamed role on lower pay to perform the same core duties is a sham
Limb 2: Award / EA Consultation (s 389(1)(b))Employer complied with every obligation in an applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement to consult about major workplace changeAnnouncing termination as a locked-in fait accompli without written change details and genuine two-way discussion (<15 small businesses are NOT exempt!)
Limb 3: Reasonable Redeployment (s 389(2))It was not reasonable in all the circumstances to redeploy the person within the employer's enterprise or any Corporations Act s 50AAA associated entityFailing to offer suitable vacant roles across group companies or ignoring reasonable operational/contractor adjustments identified by High Court authority

Under High Court authority on s 389(2), the Fair Work Commission examines objectively whether reasonable operational adjustments (including replacing external contractor labour or redeploying into sister entities) were available at the time of dismissal. Equally vital, Modern Award consultation obligations bind small and large employers alike.

Practical Takeaway: Where an ostensible redundancy targets an employee on parental leave, personal leave, WorkCover, or following a wage/Payday Super inquiry, Form F8 General Protections (21-day limit, reverse onus s 361, uncapped damages) should be assessed alongside Form F2.

2. NES redundancy pay (s 119) and minimum notice (s 117) Schedule

Where a redundancy is genuine, National Employment Standards (NES) entitlements combine (a) minimum notice or payment in lieu (s 117), (b) severance pay (s 119), and (c) accrued untaken annual leave and eligible Long Service Leave. You can compare severance payouts against unfair dismissal compensation using the Park & Co Employment Law Navigator Simulator.

Period of Continuous ServiceNES Redundancy Pay (s 119 - 15+ Staff)NES Minimum Notice (s 117 - All Employers)
Less than 1 yearNil (s 121(1)(a))1 week
At least 1 year but < 2 years4 weeks' base pay2 weeks
At least 2 years but < 3 years6 weeks' base pay2 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 3 weeks)
At least 3 years but < 4 years7 weeks' base pay3 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 4 weeks)
At least 4 years but < 5 years8 weeks' base pay3 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 4 weeks)
At least 5 years but < 6 years10 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)
At least 6 years but < 7 years11 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)
At least 7 years but < 8 years13 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)
At least 8 years but < 9 years14 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)
At least 9 years but < 10 years16 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)
At least 10 years12 weeks' base pay (reflects Long Service Leave accrual)4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old = 5 weeks)

Notice the statutory step-down at 10 years of service from 16 weeks to 12 weeks: Parliament reduced NES severance at the 10-year mark because employees typically crystallise full statutory Long Service Leave (LSL) entitlements at 10 years (and in jurisdictions such as Queensland, pro-rata LSL often triggers from 7 years upon genuine redundancy).

3. Small business exemption (s 121) and FWC variation (s 120)

  1. Small Business Exemption (<15 Headcount, s 121(1)(b)): Employers with fewer than 15 employees at dismissal (counting regular casuals and all s 50AAA associated entities) are exempt from s 119 NES redundancy pay unless an industry Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement specifies otherwise. They must still provide s 117 minimum notice (1 to 5 weeks).
  2. Other Exclusions (ss 121, 123): Less than 12 months' continuous service, casual employees, and genuine fixed-term/task completions are excluded from s 119 severance.
  3. FWC Application to Reduce Severance (s 120): Even if an employer secures other acceptable employment for the worker or faces severe financial incapacity, the employer cannot unilaterally withhold s 119 pay - it must formally apply to and obtain a determination from the Fair Work Commission under s 120.

4. Unpaid severance recovery (6 years) vs challenging sham redundancy (21 days)

Unpaid statutory redundancy pay or notice is a contravention of the NES recoverable within 6 years (s 544) (including via the expanded $100,000 Fair Work Small Claims track in the FCFCOA under s 548, filing fees $310-$585, alongside $364/PU civil penalty exposure). By contrast, challenging a sham or unconsulted redundancy via Form F2 Unfair Dismissal is governed by the strict 21-calendar-day limit.

Practical Takeaway: Never sign an employer's Deed of Release without verifying both your statutory ss 117/119 entitlements and whether a breach of s 389 gives you stronger unfair dismissal leverage.

5. Pre-consultation and settlement review checklist

Gather these seven documents before signing any separation deed or letting Day 21 pass:

  • Redundancy notice letter, restructuring announcement, and exact termination effective date (for the 21-day limit)
  • Signed employment contract, position description, and applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement name
  • Written records of any consultation invitations, change papers, or meetings held before dismissal was decided (s 389(1)(b))
  • Screenshots of any replacement job advertisements (Seek/LinkedIn) or vacant roles across s 50AAA sister companies (s 389(2))
  • Start date, date of birth (checking age 45+ extra notice week), recent payslips, and accrued annual/long service leave balances
  • Employer's draft Final Pay sheet and any proposed Deed of Release (unsigned)
  • Aggregated headcount estimate across the employer and all associated entities (<15 vs 15+ severance check)

12 November 2026 statutory audit update and employee/employer dual-perspective guide

1. Statutory audit verification (Fair Work Act 2009 (cth) ss 117–123, 389; helensburgh coal pty ltd v bartley [2025] HCA 29 [7], [34]–[41])

Genuine redundancy under section 389 requires proving that the job is no longer required, applicable Award or Enterprise Agreement consultation rules were followed, and redeployment within the employer's enterprise or an associated entity was not reasonable in all the circumstances (s 389(2)). In Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29 ([7], [34]–[41]), the High Court held that the section 389(2) redeployment inquiry is not restricted to pre-existing advertised vacancies; the Fair Work Commission may consider whether the employer could reasonably have reorganised its workforce arrangements (including insourcing work performed by contractors). However, this is not an automatic mandate to terminate contractors or create new positions; reasonableness depends on all the circumstances including contract terms, nature of work, employee skills, and retraining time. Under section 119, NES redundancy pay for non-small business employers peaks at 16 weeks for 9 to under 10 years' service and adjusts to 12 weeks at 10 or more years.

2. Redundancy consultation and redeployment audit (expansions: Employee-new-10, employer-05)

  • What Employees Should Do: Request before-and-after organisational charts, consultation documentation, associated entity lists, and details of available roles or contractor-performed work you are qualified to perform, and diarise the 21-day FWC limit from termination.
  • What Employers Must Check: Conduct genuine consultation before finalising redundancy decisions, document an objective assessment of vacancies, contractor arrangements, retraining, and associated-entity roles under Helensburgh Coal [2025] HCA 29, and ensure selection criteria are free from prohibited General Protections reasons.
  • Exceptions & Deadlines: Check section 121–123 exemptions (such as small business employers and <12 months' service) and applicable Award/Agreement severance rules; unfair dismissal challenges must be lodged within 21 days.

Pre-Consultation & Pre-Lodgement Checklist Checklist

  • Redundancy termination letter, organisational restructure notice, and exact date dismissal takes effect
  • Signed employment contract, position description, and applicable Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement title
  • Copies of any written change notices and two-way consultation records prior to the redundancy decision (s 389(1)(b))
  • Screenshots of new job ads performing your duties or vacant roles within s 50AAA sister/group companies (s 389(2))
  • Start date, date of birth (age 45+ extra notice week), recent payslips, and untaken annual / long service leave balances
  • Draft final payout sheet and any unsigned Deed of Release offered by the employer
  • Total headcount across the employer and associated entities (<15 small business exemption check under s 121)
In-Depth Column · Read Practical Background & Case Flow

"My company told me today my position is being abolished due to slower revenue. Yet less than a week later, they posted a job ad for a cheaper junior doing my exact duties. Do I just have to accept this?"

Whenever business conditions tighten, sudden "redundancy" notices surge across Australian workplaces. Many workers sign separation paperwork straight away assuming "business downturn" is an unchallengeable excuse. Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), however, the Fair Work Commission polices disguised dismissals strictly. If your employer misses even one of the three mandatory limbs of Genuine Redundancy (s 389), the redundancy shield collapses and a Form F2 Unfair Dismissal claim (21 calendar days, $92.70 fee, up to $95,050 compensation cap) opens immediately. ## Miss Any One of the Three Section 389 Gates and It Is Not a Genuine Redundancy

To establish a genuine redundancy under section 389, the employer must prove all three statutory gates. First (s 389(1)(a)), operational changes must mean your job itself no longer needs to be performed by anyone. Splitting leftover duties among existing colleagues can be legitimate, whereas tweaking a job title to hire a lower-paid replacement for substantially the same role is a classic sham redundancy. Second (s 389(1)(b)) is the hurdle employers trip over most often: strict compliance with Modern Award or Enterprise Agreement consultation clauses. Before locking in a redundancy as a done deal, an Award-covered employer must provide written details of the major change and hold genuine two-way discussions over measures to avert or mitigate job loss - and small businesses under 15 staff are NOT exempt from Award consultation. Third (s 389(2)), it must not have been reasonable to redeploy you anywhere within the employer's enterprise or any Corporations Act s 50AAA associated entity (including considering reasonable adjustments to contractor workflows under High Court principle). ## NES Redundancy Pay (s 119) and Minimum Notice (s 117) Table

Even when a redundancy is 100% genuine, the National Employment Standards (NES) require separate financial payouts: minimum notice (s 117) plus statutory redundancy pay (s 119). While small businesses with fewer than 15 aggregated staff (s 121(1)(b)), casuals, and employees under 12 months' service are generally exempt from s 119 severance (unless an Award states otherwise), every permanent worker still receives s 117 notice and accrued annual leave. | Continuous Service | NES Redundancy Pay (s 119 - 15+ Staff) | NES Minimum Notice (s 117 - All Staff) |

:---:---:---
Under 1 yearNil1 week
1 to < 2 years4 weeks' base pay2 weeks
2 to < 3 years6 weeks' base pay2 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
3 to < 4 years7 weeks' base pay3 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
4 to < 5 years8 weeks' base pay3 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
5 to < 6 years10 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
6 to < 7 years11 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
7 to < 8 years13 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
8 to < 9 years14 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
9 to < 10 years16 weeks' base pay4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)
10 years or more12 weeks' base pay (Long Service Leave offset)4 weeks (+1 week if over 45 yrs old)

Look at the bottom row. Severance peaks at 16 weeks in year 9 and drops to 12 weeks at 10+ years. That is no typo - statutory Long Service Leave normally vests at 10 years across Australian states, so the Act prevents double-counting. Unpaid statutory severance or notice can be recovered for up to 6 years via the $100,000 Fair Work Small Claims process (s 548). Before signing any Deed of Release, test your entitlements and s 389 criteria using the Park & Co Employment Law Navigator Redundancy Simulator and the Fair Work Ombudsman Redundancy Guide. If consultation was skipped or you suspect a disguised dismissal, contact us before your 21-day window closes via the Park & Co Lawyers Official Consultation Hub or enquiry@parkcolawyers.com. This article provides general Australian employment law information current as at 7 November 2026 and does not constitute legal advice for individual matters. Assessments may vary depending on applicable awards, contract terms, and specific factual circumstances.

Tailored Self-Assessment Tool

25-Modern-Award Wage Calculator & DIY FWC/Small Claims Guide

Check FY2026-27 National Minimum Wage ($26.44/hr; casual $33.05/hr), penalty rates, Payday Super (12%), and step-by-step DIY recovery guides.

Open Wage Calculator & DIY Guide ↗
[Park & Co Engagement Scope] This guide provides general information current as at 7 November 2026; no retainer arises and Park & Co Lawyers does not monitor your 21-day statutory deadline prior to a signed written agreement. Park & Co Lawyers does not perform hourly Award or payslip wage-arrears calculations.
02 Related Questions

Related Representative Questions

More in This Category
04 Park & Co Legal Services & Direct Assistance

Park & Co Lawyers · Employment Law Diagnostic Tools & Representation

Check your 21-day FWC filing limit and Modern Award rates for free first, or engage our Employment Law team for FWC advocacy, Deed of Release negotiations, and employer defence.

Open Official Inquiry Hub ↗

Solicitor Representation & HR Advisory

Employment Practice
FWC Unfair Dismissal (Form F2) & General Protections (Form F8) Representation

Drafting Form F2/F8 applications or employer Form F3/F8A response...

Employer HR Compliance, Employment Contracts & Show Cause Advisory

Modern Award classification audits, procedurally fair disciplinar...

Transparent Cost-Benefit & Engagement Scope Policy

Because Fair Work matters operate in a strict no-costs jurisdiction (s 570), Park & Co Lawyers guides small wage-arrears claims to free self-calculation tools rather than charging hourly calculation fees, focusing legal representation on high-stakes dismissal, general protections, visa-linked workplace disputes, and employer compliance.