If a Local Executive Earns Above the $190,100 High Income Threshold, Can We Terminate Them Immediately With Notice Without Risk?
Why executives above the $190,100 Unfair Dismissal cap can still bring uncapped General Protections, discrimination, and common-law reasonable notice claims
- If a local executive earns above the FY2026-27 $190,100 High Income Threshold, can we terminate their employment immediately by paying contractual notice without legal risk?
- Why do executives excluded from Unfair Dismissal bring General Protections and common-law reasonable notice claims instead?
- How can an outdated employment contract expose the company to 6 to 12 months of reasonable notice damages upon terminating a senior manager?
Earning above the FY2026-27 Fair Work High Income Threshold ($190,100, where no Modern Award or enterprise agreement applies) only excludes Part 3-2 Unfair Dismissal claims (capped at $95,050). High-earning executives routinely pursue uncapped Part 3-1 General Protections claims, implied common-law reasonable notice claims worth 6 to 12 months of remuneration, and contractual bonus or STI/LTI disputes.
- Narrow Effect of $190,100 Cap: Exceeding the $190,100 High Income Threshold (and being Award-free) only bars Part 3-2 Unfair Dismissal claims capped at $95,050.
- Uncapped General Protections: Part 3-1 General Protections claims have no income cap, uncapped compensation, and a reverse onus of proof under section 361 if the executive raised workplace complaints.
- Common-Law Reasonable Notice: If an executive's contract termination clause is defective or outdated after promotions, courts may imply 6 to 12 months of reasonable notice.
Park & Co Lawyers · Legal Consultation Guide Consultation Guide
What the $190,100 High Income Threshold covers and common calculation traps
Under section 382 of the Fair Work Act 2009, the $190,100 threshold (effective for FY2026-27) bars Unfair Dismissal access only if two strict conditions are met. First, the executive must genuinely be Award-free; if their actual duties fall within a senior classification of a Modern Award, they remain protected by Unfair Dismissal regardless of how high their salary is. Second, only guaranteed annual earnings count toward the $190,100 figure: statutory 12% Superannuation Guarantee contributions, discretionary bonuses, and unguaranteed commissions are excluded from the calculation.
Uncapped General Protections (part 3-1) and reverse onus of proof
Executives who cannot file for Unfair Dismissal frequently file a General Protections dismissal application under Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 or an anti-discrimination claim. General Protections claims have no income threshold and no statutory cap on compensation. Because senior executives regularly raise emails or internal queries regarding head office directives, financial compliance, resourcing, safety, or their own remuneration, they can readily plead that they exercised a workplace right to make a complaint or inquiry under section 341. Under section 361, the reverse onus of proof then requires the employer to prove with clear, contemporaneous evidence that the dismissal was entirely unrelated to those complaints.
Implied common-law reasonable notice and outdated executive contracts
A second major financial exposure arises under Australian common law. If an executive was promoted over several years into a Managing Director, General Manager, or Country Manager role without signing an updated executive service agreement, or if the original termination clause is drafted defectively, a court may hold that the old four-week notice clause no longer governs the relationship. In the absence of an enforceable express notice clause, Australian courts imply a term requiring reasonable notice of termination, which for senior executives typically ranges from 6 to 12 months of total remuneration package.
Pre-termination audit checklist and executive separation review
Before communicating a termination decision or initiating an exit discussion with a high-earning executive, employers should review the following six categories of documentation.
- Current employment contract and promotion letters: Confirms whether an express termination notice clause remains legally binding for the executive's current position.
- Guaranteed annual earnings calculation ($190,100 test): Verifies base salary and guaranteed non-monetary benefits excluding 12% superannuation and discretionary incentives.
- Short-term and long-term incentive (STI/LTI) plan rules: Checks leaver provisions, pro-rata entitlements, and contractual fetters on employer discretion.
- Recent 12 months of board reports, emails, and workplace complaints: Identifies any protected workplace inquiries, whistleblowing disclosures, or medical leave triggers under Part 3-1.
- Board resolution and objective performance or restructuring records: Establishes clear evidence of the genuine operational or performance reasons for the decision-maker's action.
- Post-employment restraint of trade and Deed of Release strategy: Prepares enforceable non-compete, non-solicitation, and confidential mutual separation terms.
To request a pre-termination legal risk assessment or a structured executive separation plan, please send the executive's contract, promotion history, remuneration breakdown, and proposed termination grounds to enquiry@parkcolawyers.com.
Official confirmation resources
Pre-Consultation & Pre-Lodgement Checklist Checklist
- Executed employment contract and all subsequent promotion or salary variation letters
- Guaranteed annual earnings calculation verifying the FY2026-27 $190,100 threshold excluding super and discretionary bonuses
- Short-term and long-term incentive (STI/LTI) and commission plan documentation
- Audit of recent workplace complaints, compliance queries, or leave requests raising Part 3-1 risk
- Contemporaneous board minutes and objective evidence supporting the genuine reason for termination
- Post-employment restraint clauses and draft Deed of Release terms
In-Depth Column · Read Practical Background & Case Flow
Why Paying Notice Alone Rarely Eliminates Risk When Terminating an Executive Above $190,100
When an Australian subsidiary decides to part ways with a local General Manager or senior executive, head office HR teams often check the FY2026-27 Fair Work High Income Threshold of $190,100 and assume the exit will be straightforward. Because the executive earns above $190,100, it is tempting to think that paying out four weeks of contractual notice closes the matter. ## Crossing $190,100 Blocks Unfair Dismissal but Leaves Uncapped Claims Wide Open
Earning above $190,100 (where no Modern Award applies) only removes access to Part 3-2 Unfair Dismissal, where compensation is capped at $95,050. High-earning executives instead turn to Part 3-1 General Protections claims, which carry no income cap and no ceiling on damages. If the executive ever questioned a head office directive, raised a compliance concern, or disputed a bonus calculation before being dismissed, the company bears the reverse onus of proving those complaints played no part in the termination. ## Outdated Contracts Can Trigger 6 to 12 Months of Reasonable Notice
Common-law contract claims pose an equally serious financial threat. If a manager was promoted into a senior executive role over time without executing a fresh contract, or if the original termination clause is technically defective, a court can set aside the old four-week notice provision and imply a common-law reasonable notice period of 6 to 12 months of total package. ## Audit Contracts and Bonus Rules Before Starting an Exit Conversation
Senior exits also frequently spark disputes over short-term and long-term bonuses. Even where a bonus plan is labelled discretionary, Australian courts require employers not to exercise that discretion capriciously or arbitrarily when terminating employment. Before issuing a termination letter, review the executive's original contract, promotion history, guaranteed earnings breakdown, bonus plan rules, and recent email correspondence, and consider whether a negotiated exit under a Deed of Release is safer. For a pre-termination executive risk review, please send your key documents and timeline to enquiry@parkcolawyers.com. This article provides general employment and immigration information for Australian entities and offices as at 11 November 2026 and is not legal advice on any individual matter. Outcomes may differ depending on the employer, the role, and the guaranteed pay.
Corporate Role & Sponsorship Assessment for Korean Organisations in Australia
Because the legal outcome depends on your exact corporate structure, send your entity type, target role, paying entity, work location, and current sponsorship status via our Official Inquiry Hub.