Employer Shutting Down or Phoenixing a Company? Personal Director Liability (s 550) and Criminal Wage Theft (s 327A)
Piercing defunct Pty Ltd shells via Fair Work Act s 550 personal director recovery, the FEG temporary-visa exclusion trap, and s 327A intentional wage theft penalties (10 years prison / $1.82M-$9.1M fines)
- My employer threatened to liquidate the Pty Ltd company so I get nothing, while reopening under a fresh ABN next door - can I sue the director personally?
- Does the federal Fair Entitlements Guarantee (FEG) cover unpaid wages for temporary visa holders (482, 494, 485, student, WHV) if the company goes into liquidation?
- What are the penalties for intentional criminal wage theft under Fair Work Act section 327A and how does personal accessorial liability work under section 550?
Collapsing a Pty Ltd company does not automatically shield individuals who were actually involved in a Fair Work contravention, though section 550 personal liability is not automatic from title alone and requires proving intentional participation and actual knowledge of the essential facts (EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v FWO [2018] FCAFC 134). Similarly, criminal wage theft under section 327A (in force 1 January 2025) requires intentional underpayment rather than an honest payroll or classification mistake. Where a corporate employer enters liquidation or bankruptcy, eligible citizens and permanent residents may claim covered unpaid entitlements under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) strictly within 12 months of the later of termination or the insolvency event (and before bankruptcy discharge).
- Section 550 Personal Director Liability: Collapsing a Pty Ltd company does not automatically shield individuals who were actually involved in a Fair Work contravention, though section 550 personal liability is not automatic from title alone and requires proving intentional participation and actual knowledge of the essential facts (EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v FWO [2018] FCAFC 134). Similarly, criminal wage theft under section 327A (in force 1 January 2025) requires intentional underpayment rather than an honest payroll or classification mistake. Where a corporate employer enters liquidation or bankruptcy, eligible citizens and permanent residents may claim covered unpaid entitlements under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) strictly within 12 months of the later of termination or the insolvency event (and before bankruptcy discharge).
- Critical FEG Trap for Temporary Visas: Upon formal liquidation, FEG covers unpaid wages/leave/redundancy (excluding super) ONLY for AU citizens, PRs, and NZ 444 holders. Temporary visa holders (482, 494, 485, 500, WHV) get $0 from FEG and must use s 550.
- Criminal Wage Theft (s 327A - 10 Yrs Prison): In force since 1 Jan 2025, intentional underpayment carries up to 10 years imprisonment and fines up to the greater of 3x the underpayment or $1,820,000 (5,000 PU at $364) individual / $9,100,000 (25,000 PU) corporate.
Park & Co Lawyers · Legal Consultation Guide Consultation Guide
1. Piercing the corporate collapse: Section 550 accessorial and section 558B franchisor liability
Defaulting employers frequently try to coerce workers into paltry settlements by claiming the Pty Ltd employing company has zero assets and is shutting down. While ordinary unsecured trade creditors are trapped behind corporate insolvency stays (Corporations Act 2001 s 471B / s 500(2)), section 550 (Accessorial Liability) cuts straight through the corporate shell to natural persons.
Under section 550, any individual who aided, abetted, counselled, procured, or was knowingly concerned in a Fair Work civil contravention is legally deemed to have committed the contravention personally. Settled Full Federal Court doctrine confirms that once a sole director, shadow director, HR/payroll manager, or external accountant had actual knowledge of the essential facts constituting the breach (such as hours worked, rates paid, and duties performed). Federal courts can order that individual personally to pay 100% of the unpaid wages, leave, and superannuation (s 545) plus personal civil pecuniary penalties (s 546) enforceable against their personal house and bank accounts. Where the outlet belongs to a franchise network, section 558B also exposes responsible head franchisors who knew or ought reasonably to have known of network contraventions and failed to take reasonable preventative steps.
2. The fair entitlements guarantee (FEG) safety net and the temporary visa exclusion trap
Where a corporate employer enters formal liquidation (or an individual employer enters bankruptcy), the federal Fair Entitlements Guarantee (FEG) safety net steps in to advance unpaid wages (up to 13 weeks). Accrued annual leave and long service leave, payment in lieu of notice (up to 5 weeks), and redundancy pay (up to 4 weeks per year of service), subject to the statutory weekly wage cap. Informal walk-offs or bare ASIC deregistration without a liquidator do not trigger FEG.
Korean and international workers must watch out for two critical statutory exclusions under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth):
- Superannuation Excluded: FEG never covers unpaid 12% Superannuation Guarantee arrears (which must be pursued via ATO Director Penalty Notices or s 550 claims).
- Temporary Visa Holders Ineligible (s 10(1)(g)): To qualify for FEG, the claimant must be an Australian citizen, Permanent Resident (PR), or eligible New Zealand Subclass 444 holder when employment ends. Every temporary visa holder (Subclass 482, 494, 485, Student 500, Working Holiday 417/462, Bridging visas) receives $0 under FEG! For temporary visa holders facing a collapsing employer, immediate s 550 personal claims against the director are essential before personal assets are dissipated.
| Recovery / Enforcement Mechanism | Statutory Authority | Scope & FY 2026-27 Maximum Sanctions | Visa Eligibility & Strategic Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal Director / Accessory Suit | Fair Work Act 2009 s 550 (Franchisors s 558B) | 100% personal back-pay order (s 545) + personal penalties ($21,840 standard / $218,400 serious at $364/PU) | Open to ALL workers including temporary visa holders · Survives Pty Ltd liquidation |
| Federal Safety Net (FEG) | Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 | Formal liquidation only: up to 13w wages, annual/LSL leave, 5w notice, 4w/yr redundancy (excludes super) | AU Citizens, PRs & NZ 444 ONLY (482, 494, 485, Student & WHV strictly excluded) |
| Criminal Wage Theft Offence | Fair Work Act 2009 s 327A (in force 1 Jan 2025) | Up to 10 years prison + greater of 3x underpayment or $1,820,000 (5,000 PU indiv) / $9,100,000 (25,000 PU corp) | Applies to intentional underpayment (not honest mistakes). Investigated by FWO & prosecuted by CDPP |.
| ATO Director Penalty Notice (DPN) | Tax Administration / Payday Super regime | Makes company directors personally liable for unpaid 12% Superannuation Guarantee & SGC | Applies regardless of worker's visa status via free ATO Unpaid Super reporting |
|---|
3. Criminal wage theft (section 327A), compliance code and cooperation agreements
Since 1 January 2025, section 327A of the Fair Work Act 2009 criminalises intentional conduct that results in failing to pay required statutory entitlements in full on or before the due date. Genuine payroll calculation errors or honest classification mistakes are not criminal offences, whereas deliberate wage shaving, falsified dual books, forced cashbacks, and phoenix asset-stripping sit squarely within the criminal offence.
Calculated at the 1 July 2026 Commonwealth penalty unit value of $364, criminal convictions carry up to 10 years' imprisonment for individuals alongside maximum fines equal to the greater of 3 times the underpayment amount or $1,820,000 (5,000 PU) for individuals and $9,100,000 (25,000 PU) for bodies corporate. Alongside s 327A, small business employers (<15 employees) who did not act intentionally can avoid criminal referral only by rectifying back-pay in full under the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code (s 327B), while larger employers self-reporting early may seek FWO Cooperation Agreements (s 717A) - giving well-advised employees immense pre-litigation leverage.
Practical Takeaway: If your boss shuts down Company A Pty Ltd on Friday and opens Company B Pty Ltd on Monday using the same kitchen equipment, menu, staff, and premises, photograph signage, EFTPOS receipts, and new ABNs immediately to prove phoenix continuity and s 550 knowledge.
4. Four-step urgent action plan when an employer threatens closure
Speed is decisive whenever insolvency rumours surface. First, run an ASIC Company Extract and ABN Lookup to lock down the exact corporate entity, ACN, current and former directors' full legal names and residential addresses, and whether a liquidator or administrator has been appointed.
Second, back up every SMS, KakaoTalk, WhatsApp, or email proving the individual director or manager personally set pay rates, approved rosters, or ignored underpayment complaints (vital to prove s 550 knowledge). Third, quantify your exact unpaid wages, penalty rates, leave, and 12% super using Park & Co's free 25-Award Calculator & Excel Kit. Fourth, Australian citizens and PRs facing formal liquidation should lodge FEG claims within the strict 12-month window, whereas temporary visa holders and high-value creditors should immediately seek specialist legal advice to name the individual director personally under section 550 in the general federal court jurisdiction.
Practical Takeaway: Pleading section 550 personal accessorial liability requires strict proof of each statutory element in the general FCFCOA / Federal Court division rather than an informal small claims form. Always verify director property ownership before launching contested recovery litigation.
5. Pre-litigation phoenix and director liability evidence checklist
Secure and preserve the following records immediately if your employer threatens insolvency or phoenixing:
- Current ASIC company details (ACN, ABN, trading status, and directors' full names/addresses) for both the old and any successor entity
- Direct messages, emails, rosters, or payslips showing the individual director or shadow director personally controlled pay rates and hours
- Complete bank deposit records, payslips, and superannuation fund transaction statements confirming unpaid Payday Super
- Copies of any Circular to Creditors or appointment notices issued by an external administrator or liquidator
- Proof of your visa or residency status at termination (to determine FEG eligibility vs mandatory s 550 personal recovery)
- Evidence of any head franchisor relationship (s 558B) or real property assets held personally by the company director
- Completed pay-period shortfall calculation schedule prepared via Park & Co's free 25-Award Calculator & Excel Kit
12 November 2026 statutory audit update and employee/employer dual-perspective guide
1. Statutory audit verification (Fair Work Act 2009 (cth) ss 327A, 550, 558B; fair entitlements guarantee Act 2012 (cth) ss 10–14)
Personal accessorial liability under section 550 is not automatic from holding a director, HR, or accountant title; under EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v FWO [2018] FCAFC 134 ([1], [10]–[13]), the person must be an intentional participant with actual knowledge of the essential facts constituting the contravention. Likewise, the federal criminal wage theft offence in section 327A (effective 1 January 2025) requires intentional underpayment rather than an honest payroll mistake or classification error.
2. FEG insolvency claims, adviser liability and criminal vs civil risk (expansions: Employee-new-15, employer-16, employer-18)
Under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) (Compilation No. 5, ss 10–14), FEG covers up to 13 weeks' unpaid wages, annual leave, long service leave, up to 5 weeks' notice, and up to 4 weeks' redundancy pay per year of service (subject to the Maximum Weekly Wage cap, excluding unpaid super) for eligible Australian citizens and permanent/special-category visa holders when an insolvency event occurs. The section 12 contractor-to-employee exclusion applies only where all three cumulative statutory limbs are satisfied.
- What Employees Should Do: Lodge a formal proof of debt with the liquidator and submit a valid section 14 FEG claim within 12 months after the later of the insolvency event or employment ending (and strictly before bankruptcy discharge under s 14(3)). Temporary visa holders excluded from FEG should gather evidence of who controlled payroll for a section 550 claim.
- What Employers Must Check: Do not assume outsourcing payroll to an accountant or HR officer insulates directors if warnings are ignored; audit and rectify errors immediately and preserve contemporaneous records showing lack of criminal intent.
- Exceptions & Deadlines: FEG claims expire 12 months after the later of termination or insolvency event (or upon earlier bankruptcy discharge); civil underpayment claims carry a 6-year limit (s 544).
Pre-Consultation & Pre-Lodgement Checklist Checklist
- ASIC company details (ACN, ABN, trading status, and current/former directors' names) for old and phoenix entities
- Messages, emails, rosters, or payslips proving the individual director or manager personally controlled pay rates and hours
- Bank statements, payslips, and superannuation fund logs showing unpaid wages and Payday Super shortfalls
- Any Circular to Creditors or formal appointment notices from a liquidator or voluntary administrator
- Current visa grant notice or citizenship/PR evidence to check FEG eligibility vs mandatory s 550 personal litigation
- Evidence of any franchise network connection (s 558B) or personal real estate held by the company director
- Itemised pay-period shortfall calculation completed via Park & Co's free 25-Award Calculator & Excel Kit
In-Depth Column · Read Practical Background & Case Flow
"My boss told me the company is broke and shutting down so I won't get a cent of my unpaid wages - yet he just opened the exact same restaurant under a brand-new company name! Is my money gone?"
Few moments feel more infuriating than watching an employer abandon tens of thousands of dollars in unpaid staff wages inside an empty Pty Ltd company shell, only to keep trading seamlessly under a fresh ABN with the same equipment, menu, and customers. That tactic is known across Australia as illegal phoenixing. Here is what rogue operators rarely expect you to know: shutting down or liquidating a Pty Ltd company does not wipe out personal liability under Australian workplace law. Section 550 and the section 327A criminal wage theft laws in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) pierce straight past the empty company to target the human decision-makers behind it. ## Piercing the Shell: Section 550 Personal Liability and the FEG Visa Trap
Unlike ordinary business debts, workplace underpayments trigger section 550 (Accessorial Liability). Any natural person who was knowingly concerned in the facts making up the underpayment - whether the registered director, a shadow director pulling strings behind a family member's name, a payroll manager, or even an external accountant - can be sued personally in federal court. Even after the Pty Ltd company enters liquidation, s 550 orders for 100% back-pay (s 545) and personal penalties (s 546) attach directly to the director's personal house, bank accounts, and income. If the store is part of a franchise chain, section 558B can also bring the head franchisor into the frame. There is also a critical legal trap that every Korean and migrant worker in Australia must understand. When a company enters formal liquidation, the federal government's Fair Entitlements Guarantee (FEG) safety net pays out unpaid wages, leave, notice, and redundancy (excluding superannuation) - ONLY to Australian citizens, Permanent Residents, and eligible NZ visa holders. Temporary visa holders (482, 494, 485, Student 500, and Working Holiday 417/462 visas) are statutorily excluded from FEG and receive $0! If you hold a temporary visa, pursuing the director personally under section 550 (plus ATO Director Penalty Notices for unpaid super) is your primary path to real recovery. | Recovery / Deterrence Tool | Key Rule & FY 2026-27 Figures | Visa & Strategy Takeaway |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
|---|---|---|
| Section 550 Director Personal Suit | Targets personal homes/bank accounts of directors & advisers despite Pty Ltd collapse | Available to ALL visa holders · Preserve texts proving director controlled pay |
| Federal Safety Net (FEG) | Covers unpaid wages/leave/redundancy upon formal liquidation (excludes super) | Citizens & PRs ONLY (482, 485, Student & WHV temporary visas excluded) |
| Section 327A Criminal Wage Theft | Up to 10 years prison + 3x underpayment or $1,820,000 indiv / $9,100,000 corp fine ($364/PU) | Catches intentional theft (since 1 Jan 2025) · Drives rapid full back-pay settlements |
10 Years' Prison for Intentional Wage Theft (s 327A) and Urgent Next Steps
In force since 1 January 2025. Section 327A makes intentional wage underpayment a federal crime (distinct from honest payroll mistakes). At the FY 2026-27 penalty unit rate of $364, guilty individuals face up to 10 years in prison and criminal fines up to the greater of 3 times the underpayment or $1,820,000 (5,000 PU), while companies face up to $9,100,000 (25,000 PU) or 3x the shortfall. Because small businesses (<15 staff) and corporate directors must rectify arrears promptly under the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code or FWO Cooperation Agreements to mitigate criminal exposure, well-documented pre-action demands carry real bite. If your employer shows signs of shutting down or shifting ABNs, act fast. First, record both the old and new ABNs/ACNs and directors' names, and screenshot EFTPOS receipts or signage showing business continuity. Second, back up every text or message proving the director personally knew your hours and set your pay rates. Third, quantify your exact wage, leave, and super shortfall using our free Park & Co 25-Award Wage Calculator & DIY Legal Cookbooks. Because pleading section 550 personal director liability requires precision in the general federal court track, map your position on the Park & Co Employment Law Navigator and contact us urgently via the Park & Co Official Consultation Hub or enquiry@parkcolawyers.com before company directors move personal assets out of reach. This article provides general Australian employment law information current as at 7 November 2026 and does not constitute legal advice for individual matters. Assessments may vary depending on applicable Modern Awards, contract terms, and specific factual circumstances.
25-Modern-Award Wage Calculator & DIY FWC/Small Claims Guide
Check FY2026-27 National Minimum Wage ($26.44/hr; casual $33.05/hr), penalty rates, Payday Super (12%), and step-by-step DIY recovery guides.